FederalConspiracy Charges
Aggressive federal defense against conspiracy charges involving agreements to commit federal offenses, fraud, drug crimes, and other criminal objectives.
Federal conspiracy charges represent some of the most serious and frequently prosecuted offenses in the federal criminal justice system. Under 18 U.S.C. § 371, individuals can be charged with conspiracy even if the underlying crime is never completed, as long as there was an agreement to commit a federal offense and at least one overt act taken in furtherance of that agreement. These charges carry substantial prison sentences, significant fines, and can result in devastating collateral consequences.
If you are under investigation or facing federal conspiracy charges in New York, New Jersey, or anywhere in the United States, you need experienced federal criminal defense representation immediately. At the Law Offices of Matthew Cohan, we defend clients charged under various federal conspiracy statutes in the Southern, Eastern, and Northern Districts of New York, as well as the District of New Jersey. Our firm provides aggressive representation both before and after charges are filed, protecting your rights and fighting for the best possible outcome.
What Is Federal Conspiracy?
Federal conspiracy involves an agreement between two or more individuals to commit a federal crime or to defraud the United States government. The critical aspect of conspiracy law is that the crime is complete once the agreement is made and at least one overt act is taken in furtherance of the conspiracy, regardless of whether the underlying offense is ever actually committed.
This makes conspiracy charges particularly powerful prosecutorial tools. Federal prosecutors can charge individuals with conspiracy even when they cannot prove the completion of the substantive offense. Additionally, conspiracy charges allow prosecutors to reach individuals who played organizational or leadership roles but may not have personally committed criminal acts.
To secure a conviction for federal conspiracy under 18 U.S.C. § 371, the prosecution must prove the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
1. Agreement to Commit an Offense or Defraud the United States
There must be an agreement between two or more persons either to commit any offense against the United States or to defraud the United States or any agency thereof. The agreement need not be formal, written, or explicitly stated. Courts allow juries to infer the existence of an agreement from the conduct and circumstances surrounding the alleged conspirators.
Two Types of Conspiracy Under Section 371:
Offense Conspiracy: An agreement to commit any federal crime, such as bank robbery, drug trafficking, fraud, or any other violation of federal law.
Defraud Conspiracy: An agreement to defraud the United States or its agencies. To "defraud" the government means either to obtain money or property from the government through deceit, or to obstruct, impair, or defeat the lawful functions of any governmental department or agency through deceitful means. This prong protects governmental functions from frustration and distortion through deceptive practices.
1. Agreement to Commit an Offense or Defraud the United States
There must be an agreement between two or more persons either to commit any offense against the United States or to defraud the United States or any agency thereof. The agreement need not be formal, written, or explicitly stated. Courts allow juries to infer the existence of an agreement from the conduct and circumstances surrounding the alleged conspirators.
Two Types of Conspiracy Under Section 371:
Offense Conspiracy: An agreement to commit any federal crime, such as bank robbery, drug trafficking, fraud, or any other violation of federal law.
Defraud Conspiracy: An agreement to defraud the United States or its agencies. To "defraud" the government means either to obtain money or property from the government through deceit, or to obstruct, impair, or defeat the lawful functions of any governmental department or agency through deceitful means. This prong protects governmental functions from frustration and distortion through deceptive practices.
2. Defendant Was a Member of the Conspiracy
The defendant must have been a party to or member of the agreement. The prosecution must prove that the defendant knowingly and willfully joined the conspiracy with knowledge of its unlawful purpose and with the intent to further its illegal objectives.
Mere presence at the scene of criminal activity, association with conspirators, or even knowledge that others are engaged in criminal conduct is insufficient to establish membership in a conspiracy. The defendant must have shared a unity of purpose and intent to achieve the common criminal goal.
3. Intent to Achieve the Conspiracy's Objective
The defendant must have acted with the specific intent to agree and the intent to achieve the conspiracy's unlawful objective. Federal conspiracy is a specific intent crime. The prosecution must prove that the defendant:
- Knew of the conspiracy's existence and purpose
- Knowingly and voluntarily joined the conspiracy
- Intended to further its criminal objectives
4. Overt Act in Furtherance of the Conspiracy
At least one member of the conspiracy must have committed an overt act to effect the object of the conspiracy. The overt act need not be illegal in itself. It must simply be an act knowingly committed by one of the conspirators that is in furtherance of the conspiracy's goals.
Examples of Overt Acts:
- Purchasing materials or equipment to be used in committing the crime
- Making telephone calls to arrange meetings
- Renting vehicles or properties
- Opening bank accounts
- Conducting surveillance
- Sending emails or text messages
- Meeting with co-conspirators
- Transferring money
The overt act requirement is minimal and easily satisfied. A single phone call, email, or meeting can constitute an overt act sufficient to complete the conspiracy offense.
Penalties for Federal Conspiracy Under 18 U.S.C. § 371
Imprisonment
The maximum penalty for conspiracy under 18 U.S.C. § 371 depends on the nature of the underlying offense:
Standard Maximum: If the conspiracy's object is a felony, the maximum sentence is 5 years in federal prison.
Misdemeanor Conspiracy: If the conspiracy's object is a misdemeanor, the maximum sentence cannot exceed the maximum punishment for that misdemeanor.
Important Limitation: While Section 371 itself carries a 5-year maximum, this can be highly misleading. Defendants are frequently charged with both conspiracy and the substantive offenses that are the objects of the conspiracy. These sentences often run consecutively, not concurrently, meaning a defendant could face decades in prison when conspiracy charges are stacked on top of underlying offense charges.
Fines
Individuals convicted of conspiracy face fines of up to $250,000. Organizations face fines of up to $500,000. Courts may also impose alternative fines under 18 U.S.C. § 3571 equal to twice the gross gain or twice the gross loss caused by the offense.
Restitution and Forfeiture
Courts may order restitution to victims and forfeiture of property obtained through or used to facilitate the conspiracy, depending on the nature of the underlying offense.
Collateral Consequences
A federal conspiracy conviction carries significant collateral consequences including permanent criminal record, loss of professional licenses, difficulty obtaining employment, immigration consequences for non-citizens, loss of security clearances, loss of firearms rights, and permanent damage to reputation.
Common Federal Conspiracy Charges
Federal conspiracy charges can arise under numerous statutes beyond Section 371:
21 U.S.C. § 846: Drug Conspiracy
Drug conspiracy charges apply to agreements to manufacture, distribute, possess with intent to distribute, or import controlled substances. Notably, drug conspiracy under Section 846 carries the same maximum penalty as the underlying drug offense, which can range from 10 years to life imprisonment depending on the drug type and quantity.
18 U.S.C. § 1349: Conspiracy to Commit Mail or Wire Fraud
This statute makes it a crime to conspire to commit mail fraud or wire fraud. It carries the same penalties as the underlying fraud offenses, up to 20 years (or 30 years if affecting a financial institution).
18 U.S.C. § 1962(d): RICO Conspiracy
Conspiracy to violate RICO statutes carries up to 20 years imprisonment and mandatory forfeiture provisions.
18 U.S.C. § 2339A and § 2339B: Material Support to Terrorism
Conspiracy to provide material support to terrorist organizations carries penalties up to life imprisonment depending on the circumstances.
18 U.S.C. § 1956(h): Money Laundering Conspiracy
Conspiracy to commit money laundering carries up to 20 years imprisonment per count.
Pinkerton Liability
Under the Pinkerton doctrine, a conspirator can be held criminally liable not only for the conspiracy itself but also for all reasonably foreseeable substantive crimes committed by any co-conspirator in furtherance of the conspiracy, even if the defendant did not personally participate in or have knowledge of those specific crimes.
This doctrine dramatically expands criminal liability in conspiracy cases. A low-level participant in a drug conspiracy, for example, could be held liable for murders or violent crimes committed by other conspirators that were reasonably foreseeable consequences of the drug trafficking conspiracy.
Defenses to Federal Conspiracy Charges
Defending against federal conspiracy charges requires sophisticated legal strategies and thorough investigation. Common and effective defenses include:
No Agreement Existed
The prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that an actual agreement existed. The defense may demonstrate that alleged conspirators acted independently, had separate goals, lacked communication or coordination, or that any association was innocent and lawful. Parallel conduct alone is insufficient to prove conspiracy.
Lack of Knowledge or Intent
The defendant must have knowingly and intentionally joined the conspiracy. The defense may show the defendant was unaware of the conspiracy's existence or unlawful purpose, did not share the conspiracy's criminal objectives, participated in legitimate business activities, or was deceived by other participants.
Withdrawal from Conspiracy
A defendant who voluntarily and affirmatively withdraws from a conspiracy before any overt acts are committed may have a complete defense to the conspiracy charge. Effective withdrawal requires affirmative action to disavow or defeat the conspiracy's purpose and communication of the withdrawal to co-conspirators.
No Overt Act
The prosecution must prove that at least one conspirator committed an overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy. If no such act occurred, the conspiracy charge fails. The defense may demonstrate that discussions remained purely theoretical or that no steps were taken toward accomplishing the conspiracy's objective.
Insufficient Evidence
The prosecution bears the burden of proving every element beyond a reasonable doubt. Challenging the sufficiency and credibility of the government's evidence, particularly when it relies heavily on circumstantial evidence, cooperating witnesses with credibility issues, or ambiguous communications, can create reasonable doubt.
Understanding Prosecution Strategy: We know how federal prosecutors build conspiracy cases, how they use cooperating witnesses, how they present circumstantial evidence to juries, and what weaknesses they attempt to conceal.
Challenging Cooperating Witness Testimony: Conspiracy cases often rely heavily on testimony from cooperators who have made deals with the government. We understand how these deals are structured, what motivations cooperators have to lie or exaggerate, and how to effectively cross-examine them.
Navigating Complex Evidence: Conspiracy cases typically involve voluminous evidence including wiretaps, surveillance, financial records, and electronic communications. We know how to analyze this evidence, identify exculpatory material, and challenge the government's interpretations.
Negotiating Pre-Indictment: Many conspiracy investigations last months or years before charges are filed. Our prosecutorial background enables us to engage effectively with prosecutors during investigations, potentially preventing charges or negotiating favorable resolutions before indictment.
Sentencing Advocacy: We understand federal sentencing guidelines and know how to present mitigation evidence effectively, including acceptance of responsibility, minor role reductions, and cooperation possibilities that can dramatically reduce sentences.
The Importance of Early Intervention
If you are under investigation for conspiracy, early intervention is essential. Federal conspiracy investigations typically involve grand jury subpoenas, wiretaps, surveillance, search warrants, cooperating witnesses, and extensive document review.
Early representation provides opportunities to prevent charges through pre-indictment negotiations, protect your rights during questioning, address grand jury subpoenas strategically, preserve potentially exculpatory evidence, and explore cooperation options if appropriate.
Do not speak with federal investigators without legal representation. Statements made during investigative interviews can be used against you, and lying to federal agents is itself a crime under 18 U.S.C. § 1001.
Contact Our Federal Criminal Defense Firm
Federal conspiracy charges require experienced, knowledgeable representation. At the Law Offices of Matthew Cohan, we provide comprehensive defense services to clients facing conspiracy investigations and charges throughout New York, New Jersey, and other federal jurisdictions.
Contact us today for a free, confidential consultation to discuss your case and begin building your defense. Time is critical in federal conspiracy cases. Call us or submit our online contact form. We are available to assist you in protecting your freedom and your future.
Aggravated Identity Theft charges carry a Mandatory Minimum sentence that cannot be served concurrently.
Don’t wait. Speak with an experienced criminal defense lawyer today.
Contact Us
Kew Gardens, New York 11415
Smithtown, New York 11787